The best time to find a problem with a classic car is before you own it. A careful hour with a flashlight, a magnet and a notebook can save you thousands of dollars. This is the checklist we would follow ourselves, in the order that tends to uncover the expensive surprises first.
Bring the right things
- A bright flashlight and a small inspection mirror
- A weak magnet wrapped in a soft cloth (it will not scratch paint)
- A screwdriver with a plastic handle, for gently tapping panels
- Clean rags, white paper towels and a pad of paper
- Your phone, for photographs of everything you see
Ask the seller to have the engine cold when you arrive. A cold start tells you far more than a warm one.
Start with the paperwork
Before you look at the car, look at the documents. Does the vehicle identification number (VIN) on the title match the number on the car? Do the engine and transmission numbers, where they are stamped, fit what the seller says about the car? Ask for receipts, photographs of past work, and any factory paperwork. A thick folder of records is a good sign; a vague story is not.
Rust comes first
Rust is the one problem that can cost more than the car is worth. Check the places where water collects:
- Floors and trunk floor: lift the mats and carpet, and look from underneath too
- Rocker panels and the bottoms of doors and fenders
- Around the windshield and rear window
- The frame rails and where the suspension mounts to the body
- Behind the wheels and under the battery tray
Tap lightly with the screwdriver handle. A solid ring is good. A dull thud, or a place that gives, deserves a closer look. A magnet that will not stick to a lower panel often means thick body filler underneath, though it will not work on aluminum or fiberglass bodies.
Bubbles in the paint are not the problem. They are the part of the problem you can see.
Look for signs of an accident
Walk around the car and sight along each side. Panel gaps should be even. Paint that does not quite match from one panel to the next, overspray on rubber seals, or bolts with scratched paint on their heads can all point to repairs. A repaired car is not necessarily a bad car, but you should know what was done and how well.
Under the hood and underneath
- Check the oil on the dipstick. Milky or foamy oil can mean coolant is getting in.
- Look for fresh leaks on the ground and on the underside of the engine.
- Check hoses and belts for cracks and softness.
- Look for wiring that has been spliced and taped instead of repaired properly.
If you are serious, a compression test or a leak-down test tells you the condition of the engine's internals better than anything you can see.
The test drive
Start the car cold and listen. It should idle steadily and settle down. On the road, notice:
- Does the car pull to one side under braking?
- Does the steering wander, or is there a lot of free play?
- Do you hear clunks over bumps or whining from the rear axle?
- Does the temperature gauge stay steady in traffic?
- Does the transmission shift smoothly, or slip?
Get a second opinion
If you fall for a car, pay a specialist who knows that make and model to inspect it. Their fee is small next to the price of the car, and they know where that particular model likes to hide trouble. You can search CarGuysGuide for shops that work on your kind of car. Even if you do not buy, you will have learned what to look for the next time.

